The mission:
Working alone, find people from different age groups:
Ask them the following question:
“If Congress were considering the following law:
Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof or abridging the freedom of speech or of the press, or the right of ht people peaceable to assemble, and to petition the Government for a redress of grievances.
would you approve it or not?”
- Once you have read the “law” which of course is the 1st Amendment, ask your subjects the following questions:
- Do you agree or disagree with the freedoms? Explain:
- Which do you support, and which do you think are excessive or provide too much freedom?
- Ask them if they recognize the law. NOTE how many identify the law as the 1st Amendment and if they did not.
The Responses:
Alaina (13 years old, cousin)
1. yes, because people should get to say what they want and believe what they want
2.i support free speech or of the press I think it provides too much freedom for press
3.it’s the first amendment
Starr (61 years old, mother)
Yes I’d approve it. Our country was founded on freedom – of religion as well as individual freedoms – and that should not change.
1. Do you agree or disagree with the freedoms? Explain: Yes, our right to choose how we each live our own lives is something that our country was based on and what our military fights for every day.
2. I think that our laws regarding aliens are too loose, or maybe just not enforced. If a person is going to live in the US, they should be subject to the same laws as citizens. If you don’t work, you don’t receive benefits, whether medical, food, lodging, schooling, etc. It’s only right.
3. Do you know if this is an actual law? Yes, it is a law, but again, not as well enforced as it should be.
Bryce (33 years old, brother)
1. yes I agree with freedoms, it is what makes this country this country, I don’t however agree that we should be going out and trying to make the rest of the world exactly like our country, I feel that they should be on their own. Spreading freedom? let them figure it out on their own.
2. Which laws do I support? pretty much all of them, I don’t really have any problem with any of the laws in the bill of rights, the only thing that I see as a problem is the people who want to make a deal of them in either direction. take for example gun rights, it’s all crap, people who follow the law will carry the permit and gun, and whether or not they have a permit, the criminals are going to carry regardless. but because we all have a say, let them say it.
3. did I know it was a law, um, yes. I actually have a little bit of an idea of the constitution, unfortunately, most people in this country probably don’t
Duane (31 years old, former co-worker, friend)
1. Do you agree or disagree with the freedoms? Explain:
I agree to the law. There are far too many variations and interpretations of various religious faiths (particularly of Christianity) to settle on a “true” interpretation. This is a democracy, not a theocracy. As for freedom of the press and speech, who is to tell us what can or cannot be said publicly? Without it, we would be an intellectually neutered culture/society where we cannot challenge or question authority. Those questions are what keep us pushing for new ideals and a pursuit of knowledge. Not to mention we wouldn’t have many works of literature, art, and movies
2.
All of the above have my support and I really don’t have a preference for one above the rest, they’re all rather important. There are safeguards in place for what might be considered “excessive” though. For example, you can’t holler “Fire!” in a crowded theater and we have laws for libel and slander. Nor can you hold a significant gathering (parade, protest, etc.) without a permit in some cases.
3. Do you know if this is an actual law?
It’s the First Amendment of the Bill of Rights, hooray!
Felicia (72 years old, mother’s co-worker)
would you approve it or not?” If I understand the above statement – I would not approve Congress getting involved at all in these particular rights by passing any kind of law. Besides, why would Congress even think about getting involved with that? I think they have more important issues on their plate right now. (don’t get me started….)
1. Do you agree or disagree with the freedoms? Explain: I agree with all of the freedoms listed above because that is what our country was founded on and having those freedoms is what has separated the United States from any other country in the world. Very probably one of the main reasons that people do want to live here.
2 I support all of these rights but I do think that they are easily and too often abused and probably too much freedom for some people. That is the key phrase…..some people…..and those people will do what they want and for as long as they want regardless of any laws.
3.
Didn’t respond to third question, because she believed it was not an actual law.
Wrap up: although we originally were supposed to interview six persons, only 5 responded to me within the allotted time. I find it interesting and weird that the oldest interviewee did not believe that the first amendment was an actual law, yet still she wanted to support it as if it were a law. This means that 4 out of the 5 people I interviewed knew it was an actual law, even though all 5 supported the laws wholeheartedly. I learned that I need to converse more with my mom about what exactly she seems that we as a country are not enforcing enough in regards to freedom of speech,press and religion. I also learned that my cousin doesn’t pay too much attention in school, although she identified it as the 1st amendment she contradicted her understanding of how the law is applicable to our lives.